Notice: My personal stance on AI generated artwork. Retweet and share if you agree. Let us discuss, and not immediately scream bloody murder.

Now Viewing: Subjective Tagging Discussion
Keep it civil, do not flame or bait other users. If you notice anything illegal or inappropriate being discussed, contact an administrator or moderator.

SystemError - Group: Member - Total Posts: 284
user_avatar
Posted on: 01/15/13 11:36AM

Is there any more tag to add to this?
gelbooru.com/index.php?page=post&s=view&id=1771506

Any tag for this style of colorful mishmash artworks?



Xalrun - Group: Moderator - Total Posts: 4713
user_avatar
Posted on: 01/15/13 02:49PM

SystemError said:
Is there any more tag to add to this?
gelbooru.com/index.php?page=post&s=view&id=1771506

Any tag for this style of colorful mishmash artworks?

looks like pop_art.



SystemError - Group: Member - Total Posts: 284
user_avatar
Posted on: 01/16/13 07:06AM

Probably not the best topic for this question, but I don't want to open a new one just for this...

Is there any tag here on Gelbooru for the typical im-under-ur-blanket-(planning-on-)sucking-ur-pingas situation? The one that usually involves tags such as "1girl", "naughty_face", "blush", "open_mouth", "tongue_out", "licking" and "looking_at_viewer"... And of course "blanket".
If it doesn't have an accepted tag, I would like you mods decide upon one, since it's quite a common theme.



BlueBaroness - Group: Dewrito Pope - Total Posts: 1278
user_avatar
Posted on: 01/16/13 09:46AM

SystemError said:
Probably not the best topic for this question, but I don't want to open a new one just for this...

Is there any tag here on Gelbooru for the typical im-under-ur-blanket-(planning-on-)sucking-ur-pingas situation? The one that usually involves tags such as "1girl", "naughty_face", "blush", "open_mouth", "tongue_out", "licking" and "looking_at_viewer"... And of course "blanket".
If it doesn't have an accepted tag, I would like you mods decide upon one, since it's quite a common theme.


under_covers and fellatio.

Start tagging them because it's extremely underused.



internetlovemachine - Group: Fleet Admiral Cat - Total Posts: 3836
user_avatar
Posted on: 01/16/13 10:17AM

lel Baroness' response didn't update the thread so



SystemError - Group: Member - Total Posts: 284
user_avatar
Posted on: 01/16/13 03:15PM

About the "under_covers" tag, I presume it's literally for anyone under any big object for any reason. Now then - even if I know that we try to use tag combinations of more general tags rather than more specific ones - I think it would be useful to have a separate tag for this situation.

My reasons:
- the idea of a person going/being under the blanket of another to do something sexual (usually oral sex) is imho a fairly popular concept in explicit artwork coming from Japan,
- images invoking this concept aren't necessarily explicit, i.e. sometimes there are no actual fellatio depicted (it is only planned by the character or the goal is to tease only), and without the "fellatio" tag, some would be non-explicit images with only the "under_covers" tag, even when the reason for getting under the cover is quite obvious (like because of a naughty face or the fact that one character is clearly lying on/at the other's crotch/legs), but not indicated by a tag
- you may argue that we don't tag situations because they are not inherently presented in the images, and could only be guessed, still afaik we have something like "imminent_rape" and "you_will_get_raped" or something like that, which are - most of the time - technically just guesses at situations based on the image
- this concept is used more with certain type of characters (pushy, mischievous, or probably tsundere/kuudere ones), and thus, it could be said it is something of a fetish for some people

Any reflections on this? Not trying to bitch, just like to explain my point.



BlueBaroness - Group: Dewrito Pope - Total Posts: 1278
user_avatar
Posted on: 01/16/13 03:36PM

SystemError said:
About the "under_covers" tag, I presume it's literally for anyone under any big object for any reason.


No. It's specifically for when a person or multiple people are lying under covers.

Checking before posting this would have made that obvious.

Now then - even if I know that we try to use tag combinations of more general tags rather than more specific ones - I think it would be useful to have a separate tag for this situation.


Not going to happen.

My reasons:
- the idea of a person going/being under the blanket of another to do something sexual (usually oral sex) is imho a fairly popular concept in explicit artwork coming from Japan,


Hence the tag combination.

Which you should probably be working on if you want to see it.

- images invoking this concept aren't necessarily explicit, i.e. sometimes there are no actual fellatio depicted (it is only planned by the character or the goal is to tease only), and without the "fellatio" tag, some would be non-explicit images with only the "under_covers" tag, even when the reason for getting under the cover is quite obvious (like because of a naughty face or the fact that one character is clearly lying on/at the other's crotch/legs), but not indicated by a tag


under_covers and naughty face.

Examples would have been nice, it's hard to tell you what will work with no examples.

- you may argue that we don't tag situations because they are not inherently presented in the images, and could only be guessed, still afaik we have something like "imminent_rape" and "you_will_get_raped" or something like that, which are - most of the time - technically just guesses at situations based on the image


Imminent rape is to be used when there's no other outcome but rape, this isn't a guess, it's just taking things to their logical conclusion.

You gonna get raped is a joke tag. It's misused to the point of someone (me) needing to go and fix it, but it doesn't mean what you're implying at all.

- this concept is used more with certain type of characters (pushy, mischievous, or probably tsundere/kuudere ones), and thus, it could be said it is something of a fetish for some people


When has something being a fetish for people ever dictated how we tag things? You don't see a BBW tag, do you?

If a tag combination can find what you're looking for, there's really no need to make up a new term to cover it.



Jerl - Group: The Real Administrator - Total Posts: 6711
user_avatar
Posted on: 01/16/13 04:29PM

If you want to be able to categorize a very specific subset of images like you're implying, a pool would be a much better solution than a tag anyway. Tags aren't really designed to separate images into sets. They're only supposed to describe one very specific thing in an image, in order to be able to be used in as general of a sense as possible.

Another thing to note is that we've broken down composite tags with much bigger of a presence than this before. "schoolgirl" and "catgirl" are the two major examples that come to mind.



SystemError - Group: Member - Total Posts: 284
user_avatar
Posted on: 01/16/13 05:26PM

Well okay then, better tag these images with under_covers. Probably I won't bother creating and populating a pool now, but who knows.

To say something on a positive note, I'm planning on writing some tag articles on the wiki, since it's amazing how common tags are missing. Although I would have some questions about that too.

Jerl said:
Another thing to note is that we've broken down composite tags with much bigger of a presence than this before. "schoolgirl" and "catgirl" are the two major examples that come to mind.


The catgirl one actually hurted. At least personally. :< A bit unintuitive, since pretty much everyone outside Gelbooru calls them xyzmimi or xyzgirl. BlueBaroness was the one who told me not to use stuff like "catgirl". But I'm fine with it. (Speaking of which, I seen foxgirl images tagged as kitsune when they are just kitsumimi, not mythical fox beings [i.e. "kitsune" in the western usage]. Some images of kitsune shows the so-called hoshi no tama, or spirit ball/fox fire orb/whatever, I wonder what tag should fit that? Seems like there is none currently.)

Cheers.

Edit:
Yay for the Bad Gateway and to double posting which is hated by all in Internetland.



SystemError - Group: Member - Total Posts: 284
user_avatar
Posted on: 01/16/13 05:26PM

Well okay then, better tag these images with under_covers. Probably I won't bother creating and populating a pool now, but who knows.

To say something on a positive note, I'm planning on writing some tag articles on the wiki, since it's amazing how common tags are missing. Although I would have some questions about that too.

Jerl said:
Another thing to note is that we've broken down composite tags with much bigger of a presence than this before. "schoolgirl" and "catgirl" are the two major examples that come to mind.


The catgirl one actually hurted. At least personally. :< A bit unintuitive, since pretty much everyone outside Gelbooru calls them xyzmimi or xyzgirl. BlueBaroness was the one who told me not to use stuff like "catgirl". But I'm fine with it. (Speaking of which, I seen foxgirl images tagged as kitsune when they are just kitsumimi, not mythical fox beings [i.e. "kitsune" in the western usage]. Some images of kitsune shows the so-called hoshi no tama, or spirit ball/fox fire orb/whatever, I wonder what tag should fit that? Seems like there is none currently.)

Cheers.



add_replyAdd Reply


«112113114115116 117 118119120121122»