Now Viewing: Gardener's Guild. (Arguing about catgirls since 1911 AD)
Keep it civil, do not flame or bait other users. If you notice anything illegal or inappropriate being discussed, contact an administrator or moderator.
| Yavie | Group: Moderator - Total Posts: 221 |
Quote |
Posted on: 09/10/11 05:04PM BlueBaroness said: Actually, both of them are photoshops of this one: post #239398This one: post #1282280 Poor photoshop? Smaller version of post #321373? I know it should be deleted for something. Just want to be clear on the reasoning. both have heavy jpeg artifacts too... |
| BlueBaroness | Group: Dewrito Pope - Total Posts: 994 |
 |
Posted on: 09/10/11 05:25PM Yavie said: Actually, both of them are photoshops of this one: post #239398 both have heavy jpeg artifacts too... So, delete them both? |
| F_JUNK_DUMP | Group: Moderator - Total Posts: 118 |
 |
Posted on: 09/10/11 09:27PM When was this thread made? omg I'm an oldfag member too!
|
| Vivu | Group: Member - Total Posts: 26 |
 |
Posted on: 09/11/11 03:52PM Uh, so... I guess I'm a future gardener. Though I'm not very good at it.
|
| Dante1016996 | Group: Member - Total Posts: 291 |
 |
Posted on: 09/11/11 09:47PM http://gelbooru.com/index.php?page=post&s=view&id=1283728
should this be flagged? I'm not sure if the breast are big enough to be a violatio.n |
| jedi1357 | Group: Moderator - Total Posts: 1222 |
 |
Posted on: 09/12/11 01:20AM Dante1016996 said: http://gelbooru.com/index.php?page=post&s=view&id=1283728 should this be flagged? I'm not sure if the breast are big enough to be a violatio.n Still falls under huge_breast because they are less than twice the size of her head. We keep some (917) gigantic_breasts too. If it's the kind of thing that makes you go "Whoooow! Uh, wow!" than we keep it. If it make you think "Oh my God! Eww! What has science done?" than it will likely be deleted. |
| Draq | Group: Member - Total Posts: 28 |
 |
Posted on: 09/12/11 03:44AM post #1251534
post #1251535 I've flagged both of these due to the visible brain but looking at the tagging history it looks like they've both been flagged and cleared previously. Looking for some clarity in terms of what "level" of guro is acceptable. |
| Anti_Gendou | Group: Unofficial Gardener's Guild - Total Posts: 2353 |
 |
Posted on: 09/12/11 04:24AM Somehow I would have considered that brain matter was crossing the line a bit.
In the real world, when brain matter makes an appearance outside of the body... even if you can't see a body, most detectives will tell you that they are pretty sure someone is dead out there somewhere. |
| jedi1357 | Group: Moderator - Total Posts: 1222 |
|
Posted on: 09/12/11 04:39AM Draq said: post #1251534 post #1251535 I've flagged both of these due to the visible brain but looking at the tagging history it looks like they've both been flagged and cleared previously. Looking for some clarity in terms of what "level" of guro is acceptable. Guro level aside, if you are familiar with the game, the girl and the monster then this is more humorous than grotesque. Just look at the word bubbles in the second post. You don't have to read Japanese to know she is loving life right now. |
| Jerl | Group: Moderator - Total Posts: 1889 |
 |
Posted on: 09/12/11 09:12AM Indeed; I brought it up with ILM on IRC and he said that, while the subject matter would count as grotesque, the way it is presented here wouldn't.
|
Add Reply